SkillOpt Skill — Benchmark & Optimize Agent Skills

Use Microsoft SkillOpt to evaluate and improve idev skills through trajectory-driven edits and validation-gated updates.

Activation

• User says "benchmark this skill" or "test skill quality"
• User says "optimize this skill" or "improve this skill with SkillOpt"
• User runs /idev:skillopt <skill-path>
• User wants to know if a skill actually helps the agent succeed (not just static analysis)

How It Works

SkillOpt treats the skill document as trainable state and uses a separate optimizer model to improve it through scored rollouts. The flow:

1. Generate scenarios from the skill's described behavior
2. Run rollouts — execute the skill against scenarios using the target model (Codex CLI)
3. Score results — check if the skill guided the agent to correct outcomes
4. Reflect on failures — analyze what went wrong and why
5. Propose edits — bounded add/delete/replace on the skill text
6. Validate — only accept edits that improve held-out validation scores

Prerequisites

• pip install --break-system-packages skillopt
• codex CLI installed and authenticated (codex login)
• Skill file exists at the given path

Using the Command

/idev:skillopt skills/branch-sync/SKILL.md
/idev:skillopt skills/build-check/SKILL.md --optimize

What Gets Generated

For each skill, a benchmark directory is created:

benchmarks/<skill-name>/
├── __init__.py
├── dataloader.py      # Loads test scenarios
├── evaluator.py       # Scores responses
├── rollout.py         # Runs skill against scenarios
├── adapter.py         # SkillOpt integration
├── config.yaml        # Training config
├── skills/
│   └── initial.md     # Current skill text (seed)
└── data/
    ├── train/items.json
    ├── val/items.json
    └── test/items.json

Evaluation Dimensions

Each scenario is scored on three dimensions:

A scenario passes if the weighted soft score ≥ 0.6.

After Optimization

If --optimize is used, SkillOpt produces best_skill.md — the optimized version. Review it before adopting:

1. Read the optimized skill
2. Check that it preserves the original intent
3. Verify it doesn't overfit to the test scenarios
4. Merge improvements into the original skill

Anti-Patterns

1. Do NOT optimize without test scenarios — you need data to validate against
2. Do NOT blindly adopt optimized skills — review for correctness
3. Do NOT run optimization on skills that are already passing all scenarios
4. Do NOT use a different model for optimization than what the skill targets