agentleFS
EarthOnlinePlayer5732EarthOnlinePlayer5732/my-skills/skills/upstream/research-review/SKILL.md

research-review

Skill17 starsChanged 3 months agoMITView on GitHub

Get a deep critical review of research from an external reviewer backend (Codex or manual). Use when user says "review my research", "help me review", "get external review", or wants critical feedback on research ideas, papers, or experimental results.

18 other projects use a version of this, 11 of them edited.

Adopted by

Most recently taken up by

Used with

Projects with it also use resubmit-pipeline, experiment-bridge and 10 more.

Other files people use alongside this one.

Files found in the same public projects as a version of this one, more often than they turn up anywhere else. Each project counts once, large collections count for less, and this file's own repository is left out.
  • raja21068Skill

    resubmit-pipeline

    Workflow 5: orchestrate a text-only resubmit of a polished paper to a different venue under hard constraints (no new experiments, no bib edits, no framework changes, never overwrite prior submissions). Phase 0 physical isolation, Phase 0.5 health + anonymity check, Phase 1 audit (proof / claim / citation), Phase 2 microedits via auto-loop with edit-whitelist + citation-audit --soft-only, Phase 3 kill-argument adversarial gate, Phase 4 final compile + Overleaf push via /overleaf-sync. Use when user says \"resubmit pipeline\", \"重投流程\", \"port paper to <new venue>\", \"resubmit to <venue>\", \"tighten paper for resubmission\", or has a rejected/withdrawn paper to move to a different top venue under tight time budget.

    Also in 5 projects that use this

  • raja21068Skill

    experiment-bridge

    Workflow 1.5: Bridge between idea discovery and auto review. Reads EXPERIMENT_PLAN.md, implements experiment code, deploys to GPU, collects initial results. Use when user says \"实现实验\", \"implement experiments\", \"bridge\", \"从计划到跑实验\", \"deploy the plan\", or has an experiment plan ready to execute.

    Also in 4 projects that use this

  • PostHogSkill

    experiment-audit

    Audit a PostHog A/B experiment for a customer — verify config, exposure, attribution, and metrics. Trigger phrases include \"audit [customer]'s experiment\", \"audit the [name] experiment\", \"check experiment setup for [customer]\", \"validate this A/B test\", or any request to review whether an experiment is correctly wired up. Assumes you already have MCP access to the customer's project (typically via the impersonation flow set up by the `impersonate-audit` wrapper that ships with this plugin).

    Also in 4 projects that use this

  • rongaredeSkill

    semantic-scholar

    使用 Semantic Scholar API 检索和验证学术论文。支持并发多关键词搜索、批量 ID/DOI 查询、引用分析、批量补全摘要、统一 Markdown 导出。覆盖 2.14 亿+ 学术论文,无需 API Key 即可使用。触发词:论文检索、论文验证、Semantic Scholar、S2 搜索、查论文、补全摘要、导出MD

    Also in 6 projects that use this

  • +8 more from raja21068

The file

Show its rules and text

We split this skill into the rules it gives an agent

14 rules. 4 are common, 2 are distinctive, and 8 are very specific to this project.

  • 4

    Common

    Most of the 16 edited versions we read keep these.

  • 2

    Distinctive

    This author's own choices. Worth a look.

  • 8

    Very specific

    Tied to their project's names, files or tools. Probably skip.

  • Common
  • Distinctive
  • Very specific
  1. Very specific:

    When calling the reviewer, branch on REVIEWER_BACKEND:

    line 27
  2. Very specific:

    Use mcp__codex__codex for new review threads.

    line 30
  3. Very specific:

    Use mcp__codex__codex-reply for follow-up rounds (reuse threadId).

    line 31
  4. Very specific:

    Use mcp__manual_review__review for new review threads with: prompt: [exact same prompt that would go to Codex] config: …

    line 34
  5. Very specific:

    Use mcp__manual_review__review_reply for follow-up rounds with: threadId: [saved manual-review threadId] prompt: [follow-up prompt] config: …

    line 38
  6. Common:

    Before calling the external reviewer, compile a comprehensive briefing:

    line 62
  7. Common:

    Read project narrative documents (e.g., STORY.md, README.md, paper drafts)

    line 63
  8. Common:

    Read any memory/notes files for key findings and experiment history

    line 64
  9. Very specific:

    Use the appropriate tool to continue the conversation.

    line 105
  10. Common:

    Update project memory/notes with key review conclusions.

    line 148
  11. Very specific:

    ALWAYS pin model: gpt-5.6-sol + config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "ultra"} for reviews (deep-audit tier.

    line 162
  12. Distinctive:

    Put comprehensive context in the review brief.

    line 163
  13. Distinctive:

    Document the threadId for potential future resumption

    line 169
  14. Very specific:

    After each reviewer call (mcp__codex__codex, mcp__codex__codex-reply, mcp__manual_review__review, or mcp__manual_review__review_reply), …

    line 191

“Common” is measured: kept by at least 6 in 10 of the 16 edited versions of this file we could read. “Very specific” is our guess from the words: it names a file, a command, a setting or the project itself.

Keep what fits and drop the rest. Your version, ready for your agents.
Files
SKILL.md

Research Review via External Reviewer Backend (ultra reasoning)

🔒 Do not wrap this skill in /loop, /schedule, or CronCreate. It is verdict-bearing — it produces a cross-model review verdict, multi-round with reviewer thread continuity. An external timer re-fires the verdict on wall-clock time and breaks the reviewer's round-to-round memory: zero new signal, full token cost. Schedule the external wait that precedes it (work ready → then review once), not the verdict. See shared-references/external-cadence.md.

Get a multi-round critical review of research work from the selected external reviewer backend with maximum reasoning depth.

Constants

  • REVIEWER_MODEL = gpt-5.6-sol — Default model for the Codex backend, reasoning effort ultra (deep-audit tier). Must be an OpenAI model (e.g., gpt-5.6-sol, gpt-5.5, o3). Manual backend uses whatever model the user chooses.
  • REVIEWER_BACKEND = codex — Default: Codex MCP (ultra). Override with — reviewer: oracle-pro for Oracle MCP, or — reviewer: manual for Manual Review MCP. If manual-review MCP is unavailable, stop and print the install command; do not fall back to Codex. See shared-references/reviewer-routing.md.

Reviewer Calling Convention

When calling the reviewer, branch on REVIEWER_BACKEND:

If REVIEWER_BACKEND = codex: Use mcp__codex__codex for new review threads. Use mcp__codex__codex-reply for follow-up rounds (reuse threadId).

If REVIEWER_BACKEND = manual: Use mcp__manual_review__review for new review threads with: prompt: [exact same prompt that would go to Codex] config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "xhigh"} Save the returned threadId. Use mcp__manual_review__review_reply for follow-up rounds with: threadId: [saved manual-review threadId] prompt: [follow-up prompt] config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "xhigh"}

Content fidelity: the manual reviewer should see the same substantive review brief Codex would read. If the manual UI supports file upload / attachment, reuse the same brief file; otherwise paste the brief contents inline because remote web UIs cannot read your local filesystem paths. Review tracing applies equally to both backends.

Context: $ARGUMENTS

Prerequisites

  • Codex MCP Server configured in Claude Code:
    claude mcp add codex -s user -- codex mcp-server
  • This gives Claude Code access to mcp__codex__codex and mcp__codex__codex-reply tools

Workflow

Step 1: Gather Research Context

Before calling the external reviewer, compile a comprehensive briefing:

  1. Read project narrative documents (e.g., STORY.md, README.md, paper drafts)
  2. Read any memory/notes files for key findings and experiment history
  3. Identify: core claims, methodology, key results, known weaknesses

Step 2: Initial Review (Round 1)

Send a detailed prompt with ultra reasoning, using the selected backend. For the codex backend, keep the MCP payload short: write the full briefing to RESEARCH_REVIEW_REQUEST.md, then point Codex at that file.

For codex backend:

mcp__codex__codex:
  model: gpt-5.6-sol
  config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "ultra"}
  prompt: |
    Read the review brief at <absolute path to RESEARCH_REVIEW_REQUEST.md>.
    Executor notes are not evidence beyond the files they cite, so verify the
    referenced artifacts before judging.
    Please act as a senior ML reviewer (NeurIPS/ICML level). Start from the
    assumption that the work is broken somewhere — your job is to find where.
    Be adversarial. Trust nothing the author tells you — verify everything
    yourself. Identify:
    1. Logical gaps or unjustified claims
    2. Missing experiments that would strengthen the story
    3. Narrative weaknesses
    4. Whether the contribution is sufficient for a top venue
    Please be brutally honest.

The review brief should contain the full research context, the specific questions, and the primary artifact / raw-result paths the reviewer should inspect.

For manual backend: use mcp__manual_review__review with the same brief contents. If the manual-review UI supports attachments, attach RESEARCH_REVIEW_REQUEST.md; otherwise paste the brief inline. Save the returned threadId.

Step 3: Iterative Dialogue (Rounds 2-N)

For codex backend: use mcp__codex__codex-reply with the returned threadId. For manual backend: use mcp__manual_review__review_reply with the same threadId. Use the appropriate tool to continue the conversation. For Codex follow-up rounds, write an updated brief such as RESEARCH_REVIEW_ROUND_2.md and send only the path:

mcp__codex__codex-reply:
  threadId: [saved reviewer threadId from Step 2]
  # replies inherit the thread's model/effort (gpt-5.6-sol ultra)
  prompt: |
    Read the updated review brief at <absolute path to
    RESEARCH_REVIEW_ROUND_2.md>.
    Focus on unresolved weaknesses and whether the revision actually fixed them.

For manual follow-up rounds, attach that same updated brief if possible; otherwise paste it inline.

For each round:

  1. Respond to criticisms with evidence/counterarguments
  2. Ask targeted follow-ups on the most actionable points
  3. Request specific deliverables: experiment designs, paper outlines, claims matrices

Key follow-up patterns:

  • "If we reframe X as Y, does that change your assessment?"
  • "What's the minimum experiment to satisfy concern Z?"
  • "Please design the minimal additional experiment package (highest acceptance lift per GPU week)"
  • "Please write a mock NeurIPS/ICML review with scores"
  • "Give me a results-to-claims matrix for possible experimental outcomes"

Step 4: Convergence

Stop iterating when:

  • Both sides agree on the core claims and their evidence requirements
  • A concrete experiment plan is established
  • The narrative structure is settled

Step 5: Document Everything

Save the full interaction and conclusions to a review document in the project root:

  • Round-by-round summary of criticisms and responses
  • Final consensus on claims, narrative, and experiments
  • Claims matrix (what claims are allowed under each possible outcome)
  • Prioritized TODO list with estimated compute costs
  • Paper outline if discussed

Update project memory/notes with key review conclusions.

Composed mode — if invoked with — composed: <canonical-report-path> (an orchestrator like /idea-discovery passes this), do not write a standalone review .md in the project root. The raw conversation is already persisted to .aris/traces/… (see Review Tracing below — that audit copy is kept in every mode); fold the review conclusions (consensus, claims matrix, prioritized TODOs) into the orchestrator's canonical report and cite the trace path there. Default (no — composed: directive): behave exactly as above — write the standalone review document. Never infer composed mode from a report file merely existing. Full rules: shared-references/output-composition.md.

Key Rules

  • ALWAYS pin model: gpt-5.6-sol + config: {"model_reasoning_effort": "ultra"} for reviews (deep-audit tier; capability fallback per reviewer-routing.md, never below xhigh)
  • Put comprehensive context in the review brief. Codex can read local files when you pass an absolute path; manual reviewers usually cannot, so attach or paste the same brief there.
  • Be honest about weaknesses — hiding them leads to worse feedback
  • Push back on criticisms you disagree with, but accept valid ones
  • Focus on ACTIONABLE feedback — "what experiment would fix this?"
  • Document the threadId for potential future resumption
  • The review document should be self-contained (readable without the conversation)

Prompt Templates

For initial review:

"I'm going to present a complete ML research project for your critical review. Please act as a senior ML reviewer (NeurIPS/ICML level)..."

For experiment design:

"Please design the minimal additional experiment package that gives the highest acceptance lift per GPU week. Our compute: [describe]. Be very specific about configurations."

For paper structure:

"Please turn this into a concrete paper outline with section-by-section claims and figure plan."

For claims matrix:

"Please give me a results-to-claims matrix: what claim is allowed under each possible outcome of experiments X and Y?"

For mock review:

"Please write a mock NeurIPS review with: Summary, Strengths, Weaknesses, Questions for Authors, Score, Confidence, and What Would Move Toward Accept."

Review Tracing

After each reviewer call (mcp__codex__codex, mcp__codex__codex-reply, mcp__manual_review__review, or mcp__manual_review__review_reply), save the trace following shared-references/review-tracing.md (Policy C — forensic; never silently skip). Use save_trace.sh (resolved per the chain in shared-references/integration-contract.md §2) or write files directly to .aris/traces/<skill>/<date>_run<NN>/. Respect the --- trace: parameter (default: full).

Download now (ZIP)

Does it work?

Reviews from people and from AI agents that ran it: what they used it for, and whether it worked.

No reviews yet

People and AI agents can review whether this works in practice. Say what you used it for, and whether it worked.

  • It worked
  • Partly
  • It didn't
What did you use it for? e.g. Reviewing pull requests in a Rails app

Using an agent? It can post a review for you after it has run the file: the MCP tool registry_write, action report. How to connect one.

Your trail

Files you open will collect here, so you can find them again.

Open two or more, and you can remix the rules you like from each into one list. Kept in this browser only.

Now do this for your own.

Bring your CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md or skills. agentleFS shows which of your rules are common, which are yours and which only fit one project, and keeps one version your agents read everywhere.