React Best Practices for Code Review

Supplement to the standard code review checklist. Covers judgment calls that linters and static analysis cannot catch.

When to Use

During code review when the diff contains React code (.tsx, .jsx, or .ts files importing from "react").

Apply these checks after the standard code quality review, as an additional pass.

Review Checklist

Check each section below. Flag violations as Important or Minor per the standard review severity levels.

1. Component Responsibility & Size

A component is too large when it mixes concerns, not when it exceeds a line count.

Flag when a single component does more than one of:

• Renders UI (view layer)
• Contains business logic (data transformation, validation, calculations)
• Manages complex state interactions (multiple related useState + useEffect)
• Fetches data

The fix pattern:

• View logic stays in the component (JSX, conditional rendering, layout)
• Business logic moves to pure functions (sorting, filtering, formatting, validation). Pure functions are trivially testable without rendering.
• Complex state + effects move to custom hooks (useOrders, useAuth, useSettings). A hook is "complex" when it combines multiple useState calls that interact with each other or with useEffect.

// BAD: all mixed in one component
function Dashboard() {
  const [orders, setOrders] = useState([]);
  const [sorted, setSorted] = useState([]);
  useEffect(() => { fetch(/*...*/) }, []);
  useEffect(() => { setSorted(orders.sort(/*...*/)) }, [orders]);
  const formatPrice = (n: number) => /*...*/;
  return <table>...</table>;
}

// GOOD: separated by responsibility
function Dashboard() {
  const { orders, sort, sortField } = useOrders();  // custom hook: state + fetching
  return <OrdersTable orders={orders} onSort={sort} sortField={sortField} />;
}
// sortOrders(), formatPrice() are pure functions in a utils file

2. useEffect Misuse

Linters catch missing dependencies. They cannot catch unnecessary effects.

Flag these patterns:

useEffect is ONLY for synchronizing with external systems (subscriptions, timers, DOM manipulation, third-party widgets).

3. React Version-Appropriate Patterns

Check package.json for the React version. Review for patterns appropriate to that version.

React 19+ apps should use:

useActionState signature reminder: (prevState, formData) => newState — first arg is previous state, not formData. Imported from "react", not "react-dom".

useFormStatus rule: Must be called from a child component rendered inside the <form>, not in the same component that renders the form.

4. Accessibility Beyond Linting

eslint-plugin-jsx-a11y catches static markup issues. These behavioral issues require judgment:

Focus management:

• Modal/dialog: trap focus inside, return focus to trigger on close
• Route changes in SPAs: announce new page to screen readers
• Form errors: move focus to error summary or first invalid field
• Success/error messages: use role="alert" or aria-live="polite" so screen readers announce them

Keyboard navigation:

• Every interactive element must work with keyboard (Tab, Enter, Space, Escape, Arrow keys)
• <div onClick> is never a button — use <button> (linter catches some, not all)
• Custom sort controls, dropdowns, tabs need keyboard handlers

Color:

• Status indicators (error, success, pending) must not rely on color alone — add icons, text labels, or patterns

5. Testing Practices

Query priority (most to least preferred):

1. getByRole — validates accessibility at the same time
2. getByLabelText — best for form fields
3. getByText — for non-interactive content
4. getByTestId — last resort only

Interaction:

• Use userEvent (simulates real user behavior: focus, keyboard, hover) not fireEvent (dispatches a single DOM event)

What to test:

• What the user sees and does — rendered output, interaction results, accessible names
• NOT implementation details — internal state, hook calls, re-render counts, component instance methods

Mocking:

• Mock at the network boundary with MSW (Mock Service Worker), not by replacing global.fetch or mocking component imports
• If you're testing mock behavior instead of real behavior, the test is wrong