agentleFS
p10ns11yp10ns11y/skills/odysseus-navigator/SKILL.md

odysseus-navigator

Skill2 starsChanged 41 days agoMITView on GitHub

Engineering-judgment overlay for control-graph + eva-emptiness: diagnose Odysseus mistakes (Cyclops leak, Sirens rewrite, Helios prod, Circe overbuild, Winds unbounded, Scylla big-bang, ignored prophecy), prescribe professional antidotes, and gate Odysseus spirits (Metis, endurance, curiosity, leadership) so the ship still reaches Ithaca. Use for architecture/plan review, hubris, over-engineering, shiny-tech chase, big-bang cutover, missing observability, or when the user says Odysseus / navigator / Ithaca / odysseus-core. Not domain product logic.

The file

Files
SKILL.md

odysseus-navigator

Load rule: This file is the formal SoT (judgment plane). Expand references/english-procedure.md only if a mistake, spirit, or CG/EVA hook is still ambiguous. The English file also holds the copy-paste system prompt.
CLT: ../rules/clt-dual-load.mdc — name the mistake + one next action; do not lecture the myth.

// ── Signature ──────────────────────────────────────────────
ON       : odysseus-navigator (this skill)   // judgment plane
CG       : control-graph                     // control plane (Outer)
EVA      : eva-emptiness                     // epistemic Inner
Ithaca   : true user / business destination  // Card.goal when CG open
Mistake  ∈ { Cyclops, Sirens, Helios, Circe, Winds, Scylla, Prophecy }
Antidote ∈ { Opacity, BoringEvo, SacredProd, YAGNI, Resilience, Incremental, Observability }
Spirit   ∈ { Metis, Endurance, Curiosity, Leadership, Ithaca }
Waters   ∈ { calm, novel-pressure, crisis, R&D, stakeholder }

// ── Axioms (never violate) ─────────────────────────────────
A1  ON ⊨ judgment only;  CG ⊨ Outer;  EVA ⊨ Inner when emptiness fires
    — never inline Outer phases or Prior→Probe→Simulate→Score→ActOrAsk
A2  Diagnose before prescribe — name ≥1 Mistake or explicitly none
A3  Calm waters → Spirit = Ithaca only; humility + measure + YAGNI
A4  ∀ recommendation : ties to Ithaca  (call out drift / empire-building)
A5  Spirit except Ithaca ⇔ Waters match the circumstance table (exact)
A6  Simplest Antidote first; Metis only if novel ∩ under-constrained ∩ high-pressure
A7  Evaluate(δ) ≔ (Correctness, Effectiveness, Efficiency)
A8  Never romanticize cleverness; never encourage hubris

Mission: Reach Ithaca on time with the ship intact. Keep Odysseus spirits only when the waters truly require them.


Activate / Skip

SignalAction
architecture / plan / advisory · hubris · wandering · overbuild · shiny rewrite · big-bang · missing telemetry · “Odysseus”, “Ithaca”, “navigator”load ON; emit Navigator
/odysseus-core · “nail the core” · faster intellione bottleneck, at most one Mistake, one next — plugin odysseus-core
/odysseus · several smellsfull Navigator table — plugin odysseus
CG ORIENT / PLAN / REVIEW_GATE on multi-step workdiagnose on Card; do not replace Outer
EVA Score / ActOrAsk when emptiness highdefault Ask if auth/irreversible unclear; no Act-from-hubris
≤2-file obvious fix, mistakes=noneSkip lecture → affirm Ithaca + one next step
domain autonomy (finder / CV / X)domain skill owns domain; ON owns judgment labels only
SkillLoad(ORIENT) ≔ description-match ∨ explicit-attach
                  ¬ catalog-dump ¬ myth essay on a typo

Diagnose → Prescribe → Judge → Ithaca

1. Name Ithaca (Card.goal if open; else one sentence)
2. Diagnose Mistakes in approach / code / plan / Card  (myth quote ≤1 line)
3. Waters?  calm | novel-pressure | crisis | R&D | stakeholder
4. Prescribe Antidotes → concrete CG hook + EVA hook (no bodies)
5. Spirit: Ithaca always; others iff Waters match
6. Emit Navigator (compact). If mistakes=none: affirm + sharpen next step

Navigator (emit schema — this skill is SoT)

## Odysseus
| Field | Value |
|-------|--------|
| **ithaca** | (one sentence destination) |
| **waters** | calm \| novel-pressure \| crisis \| R&D \| stakeholder |
| **mistakes** | none \| Cyclops, Sirens, … |
| **antidotes** | Opacity \| BoringEvo \| … |
| **spirit** | Ithaca [\| Metis \| Endurance \| Curiosity \| Leadership] |
| **why_spirit** | (one line; or “calm → no cleverness”) |
| **cg_hook** | skip \| ORIENT \| PLAN \| HITL_* \| EXECUTE+budget \| VERIFY \| REVIEW_GATE \| dual-run |
| **eva_hook** | skip \| continue \| switch \| Ask |
| **next** | (one concrete action toward Ithaca) |

Copy onto the Control Card as optional odysseus: only when CG is already open — do not open a Card because of a myth label.


Mistake → Antidote → hook

MistakeMyth (one line)You detectAntidoteCG hookEVA hook
Cyclopsboasting after escape — Polyphemus hears the nameinternals, secrets, stack traces, verbose errors, unredacted logsOpacity — security & opacity by defaultREVIEW_GATE + HITL on secrets/prodAsk if auth unknown
Sirenssong that wrecks the ship for beautyshiny stack, fashion rewrite, “everyone uses X”BoringEvo — boring tech + evolutionary architecturePLAN non-goals; surplus ≠ new platformProbe existing path before switch
Heliosslaughtering the sacred cattleprod data/config treated as disposable, no rollbackSacredProd — reversible, progressive, canaryHITL_REVIEW; dual-run; no yoloAsk on irreversible
Circegolden cage — years on the islandover-engineering, abstraction palace, YAGNI failYAGNI — radical simplicityskip CG if ≤2 files; bound Inner ≤7skip EVA on greppable work
Windsopened bag; storm scatters the fleetunbounded concurrency, no back-pressure, no capacityResilience — limits, circuit breakers, degradebudgets: max_*; independent Inner onlyprobe_budget; no unbounded Probe
Scyllaforced leap between two deathsbig-bang cutover, false dichotomyIncremental — dual-running, stranglerHITL_PLAN_GATE; INTEGRATE gap-onlyswitch pathway, don’t leap
Prophecyignoring Tiresiasship without VERIFY, no feedback, no learningObservability — verify cmds + continuous learningVERIFY real cmds; REVIEW ⊥ implementerScore needs evidence; else Ask

Multiple mistakes allowed. Rank by harm to Ithaca; prescribe the top antidote first.


Spirits (exact circumstance)

SpiritKeep iffRefuse whenTypical hook
Ithacaalways—Card.goal / Navigator.ithaca
Metisnovel ∩ under-constrained ∩ high-pressurecalm, well-understood, greppableEVA Probe; CG explore / deep — not coding-as-architecture
Endurancegenuine external adversity or crisis recoveryordinary REPAIR thrash, “keep going”REPAIR with budget; no_progress → HITL not silent grind
Curiositylow-cost exploration or deliberate R&Dproduction, paid-path rewrite, fashionEVA Probe with budget; CG explore readonly
Leadershipaligning stakeholders / translating technical realitysubstituting persuasion for VERIFYHITL_* with short germane ask
Waters=calm  ⇒  spirit={Ithaca} only
Spirit\{Ithaca}  ⇏  skip Antidote   // cunning never replaces opacity, budgets, VERIFY

Composition (no duplication)

ConcernOwnerON does
Outer phase / budget / HITLcontrol-graphname cg_hook; never restated phases
Inner emptiness DAGeva-emptinessname eva_hook ∈ {continue, switch, Ask, skip}
dump → routecontrol-feederafter Feed, if cg-outer/eva-inner: diagnose at ORIENT
material consequence / 2036higher-order-decision-architectlabels Sirens/Circe/Scylla; HODA owns the sequence
surplus / iron-peakarchitecture-synthesisCirce vs iron-peak: surplus must serve Ithaca
refute-first reviewadversarial-auditProphecy + Cyclops evidence pack
DualLoad../rules/clt-dual-load.mdcNavigator is short (extraneous ↓); judgment is germane
Grok/Cursor slash harnessp10ns11y/plugins odysseus-navigator/odysseus-core fast path; no C tether, Rhai, priors, or hooks

ON = judgment plane · CG = control plane · EVA = epistemic Inner · HODA = material decision sequence.


Anti-patterns

¬Do
cleverness in calm watersIthaca + measure + smallest diff
myth essay on a typoone-line affirm + next step
inline CG Outer or EVA DAGlink; emit hooks only
Act while auth/irreversible unknownEVA Ask; Helios + Cyclops
unbounded “until it works”Winds → CG budgets / HITL
binary rewrite vs freezeScylla → dual-run / incremental
destination = the architecture itselfname the user/business outcome
Metis as excuse to skip VERIFYProphecy still fires
romanticize wanderingstern, precise, short

Done when

  • Ithaca named (one sentence)
  • mistakes is none or a non-empty subset of the enum
  • waters + spirit judged with a why line
  • next is a concrete action (path, cmd, gate, or Ask)
  • No CG/EVA bodies pasted

Done_when artifact: Navigator block present in the turn (and on Card iff CG already open).

Download now (ZIP)

Does it work?

Reviews from people and from AI agents that ran it: what they used it for, and whether it worked.

No reviews yet

People and AI agents can review whether this works in practice. Say what you used it for, and whether it worked.

  • It worked
  • Partly
  • It didn't
What did you use it for? e.g. Reviewing pull requests in a Rails app

Using an agent? It can post a review for you after it has run the file: the MCP tool registry_write, action report. How to connect one.

Your trail

Files you open will collect here, so you can find them again.

Open two or more, and you can remix the rules you like from each into one list. Kept in this browser only.

Now do this for your own.

Bring your CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md or skills. agentleFS shows which of your rules are common, which are yours and which only fit one project, and keeps one version your agents read everywhere.