agentleFS
justice8096justice8096/dyscalculia-support-skill/skills/remediation-strategies/SKILL.md

remediation-strategies

Skill0 starsChanged 7 months agoCC0-1.0View on GitHub

Generate CRA-based remediation plans with concrete manipulatives, representational models, and abstract symbol work. Customizable by student anxiety level, duration, intensity, and comorbidities. Locale-aware adaptations: French intervention via orthophoniste with explicit attention to irregular number-word transcoding (60-99 range); Spanish intervention leveraging transparent base-10 system to emphasize fluency over accuracy.

1 other project uses a version of this.

Adopted by

Most recently taken up by

  • Other versions1 project uses a version of this.

    Word for word · 0

    None found.

    Edited · 0

    None found.

    Wrote their own version · 1

    1. justice8096/dyslexia-support-skill★ 0same name

    How matches are found. Word for word: the exact same text. Edited: shares passages with this file (“99% same” means 99% of its five-word phrases also appear here; 10% or more counts). Their own version: similar meaning, or, weakest, the same name. We can’t tell which project had it first. Projects are counted among the 200 most-starred candidates, and mentions are links to the repository we found, up to 50 per site, so both counts are a floor.

  • In this repository3 other files it gives its agents.

The file

Show its rules and text

We split this skill into the rules it gives an agent

13 rules. About 0 are common, 13 are distinctive, and 0 are very specific to this project.

  • ≈0

    Common · estimate

    Many files like this have a rule of this kind.

  • ≈13

    Distinctive · estimate

    This author's own choices. Worth a look.

  • 0

    Very specific

    Tied to their project's names, files or tools. Probably skip.

  • Common
  • Distinctive
  • Very specific
  1. Distinctive:

    Only after robust concrete and representational competence

    line 29
  2. Distinctive:

    Example Strategy: Use songs, rhythmic counting patterns, and verbal rehearsal

    line 114
  3. Distinctive:

    Every remediation plan should explicitly identify which skills are remediation targets (expected to improve) and which are bypass targets …

    line 181
  4. Distinctive:

    Intensity gap flag: When generating remediation plans for French students, explicitly flag that the standard 1-2x/week orthophonie cadence …

    line 258
  5. Distinctive:

    When generating a remediation plan for a French student:

    line 287
  6. Distinctive:

    Acceptance of Belgian/Swiss regular forms: when student has been exposed to them.

    line 291
  7. Distinctive:

    When generating remediation plans for Spanish students, shift priorities relative to English/French:

    line 354
  8. Distinctive:

    When generating a remediation plan for a Spanish student:

    line 366
  9. Distinctive:

    Always prioritize understanding the WHAT and WHY before WHEN and HOW

    line 381
  10. Distinctive:

    Avoid procedural memorization divorced from concrete understanding

    line 383
  11. Distinctive:

    Create a safe learning environment.

    line 391
  12. Distinctive:

    Use language carefully: "That's a learning opportunity, not a mistake"

    line 392
  13. Distinctive:

    locale=es (Spanish students): Do NOT default to French-style transcoding-focused intervention — Spanish base-10 is transparent.

    line 403

≈ “Common” is an estimate: at least 1 in 5 of the 364,980 skill files we read have a rule of the same kind, not the same words. “Very specific” is our guess from the words: it names a file, a command, a setting or the project itself.

Keep what fits and drop the rest. Your version, ready for your agents.
Files
SKILL.md

Dyscalculia Remediation Strategies

Evidence-based dyscalculia intervention framework grounded in the Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) methodology—the foundational approach proven most effective for remediating number sense and calculation deficits.

Core Concepts

Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) Methodology

CRA is the research-validated instructional progression for dyscalculia remediation:

  1. Concrete Stage (Physical Manipulatives)
    • Students interact with physical objects: base-10 blocks, counters, money, Stern materials
    • Builds neural pathways for quantity and magnitude understanding
    • Prerequisite: Never skip this stage—cognitive neuroscience shows dyscalculic brains require extended concrete experience
    • Duration: Multiple lessons per concept; progress only when mastery is evident
  2. Representational Stage (Pictorial/Drawn Models)
    • Students draw, diagram, or sketch representations
    • Bridges from physical to symbolic thinking
    • Examples: tally marks, ten-frames, number lines, arrays, area models
    • Develops mental imagery of quantity
  3. Abstract Stage (Symbolic/Procedural)
    • Students work with numbers and algorithms
    • Only after robust concrete and representational competence
    • Reduces cognitive load by building on established neural pathways

Key Principle: Progress is determined by demonstrated understanding at each stage, not grade level or age.

Multisensory Math Instruction

Effective dyscalculia instruction engages multiple sensory pathways:

  • Tactile: Manipulatives with varied textures (sandpaper numerals, textured blocks, beaded strings)
  • Kinesthetic: Finger counting, body-based magnitude estimation, walking number lines
  • Visual: High-contrast numerals, color-coded place value, animated magnitude demonstrations
  • Auditory: Counting chants, verbal skip counting, rhythm-based practice
  • Proprioceptive: Weighted manipulatives, pressure-based number exploration

Multisensory redundancy strengthens encoding and retrieval across distributed neural networks.

Evidence-Based Programs

TouchMath

  • Framework: Concrete-representational bridge using tactile numerals with raised "touch points"
  • Target: Number sense, basic operations (addition, subtraction to 10 and beyond)
  • Mechanism: Students touch numbered dots on numerals to count, reducing cognitive load on working memory
  • Grade Range: K-8 (adapted by skill level)
  • Dyscalculia Fit: Excellent for kinesthetic learners; bridges concrete and abstract naturally

Number Worlds

  • Framework: Year-long sequential program building number sense progressively
  • Core Domains: Quantity, magnitude, subitizing, comparing, ordering, operations, fractions
  • Instructional Model: Large group, small group, individual stations with manipulatives
  • Research Base: Focuses on foundational number sense as prerequisite to computation
  • Dyscalculia Fit: Explicitly targets number sense deficits; flexible pacing allows extended concrete stages

Stern Structural Arithmetic

  • Framework: Wooden golden beads and materials; visual and tactile place value system
  • Core Insight: Represents numbers as actual quantities (ones, tens, hundreds, thousands)
  • Advantages: Transparent place value relationships; supports sensory engagement
  • Operations: Addition, subtraction, multiplication, division with structural understanding
  • Dyscalculia Fit: Exceptional for students who struggle with abstract place value concepts

Singapore Math Adaptations

  • Framework: Model-Dependent Problem Solving; bar models for visualization
  • Core Strategy: Visual representation of problem structure before symbolic manipulation
  • Strengths: Develops mathematical reasoning; reduces procedural memorization
  • Adaptation for Dyscalculia: Extend concrete/representational stages; provide manipulative models before bar diagrams
  • Key Difference: Singapore Math assumes stronger early number sense; dyscalculia adaptations must rebuild foundations first

Strategic Math Series

  • Framework: Cognitive strategy instruction with explicit metacognitive scaffolding
  • Approach: Teach WHY strategies work, not just WHAT to do
  • Components: Strategy development, guided practice, generalization to new contexts
  • Dyscalculia Fit: Addresses working memory limitations through external cognitive supports

Number Sense Foundations

Number sense is the prerequisite to all mathematics. Dyscalculia interventions must prioritize:

Subitizing (Instant Quantity Recognition)

  • Ability to recognize quantity without counting (up to ~4-5 items)
  • Often underdeveloped in dyscalculia; requires targeted, repeated practice
  • Instruction: Present collections (fingers, dots, objects) and practice instant recognition
  • Progress: Start with 1-3, gradually move to 4-5
  • Benefits: Reduces cognitive load on working memory, supports counting and computation

Magnitude Comparison

  • Understanding and comparing relative size of quantities
  • Foundational to ordering, estimating, and computational sense
  • Instruction: "Which is more? 3 or 7? By how much?"
  • Visual aids: Number lines, Rekenrek (bead string), ten-frames
  • Neural basis: Activates intraparietal sulcus (IPS), the neural basis of numerical magnitude

Quantity Visualization

  • Mental imagery of quantities (without objects present)
  • Bridges concrete manipulatives to abstract numbers
  • Instruction: "Close your eyes. Imagine 5 pennies. Can you see them?"
  • Progressive scaffolding: Reduce visual aids gradually as imagery improves

Kosc's Six Subtypes and Targeted Remediation

Kosc's classification identifies distinct dyscalculia profiles requiring different intervention emphases:

1. Verbal Dyscalculia

  • Deficit: Number naming, counting sequences, number fact retrieval
  • Symptoms: Difficulty reciting number names, counting errors, trouble learning facts by rote
  • Intervention Priority: Auditory-verbal repetition, chanting, rhythm-based practice; multisensory number naming
  • Example Strategy: Use songs, rhythmic counting patterns, and verbal rehearsal

2. Practognostic Dyscalculia

  • Deficit: Spatial arrangement of numerals, finger gnosia (finger awareness)
  • Symptoms: Difficulty with place value, transposition errors, awkward finger use
  • Intervention Priority: Spatial manipulation training, structured finger activities, explicit place value work
  • Example Strategy: Stern materials with clear spatial columns; finger-based subitizing

3. Lexical Dyscalculia

  • Deficit: Reading and writing numerals and mathematical symbols
  • Symptoms: Difficulty recognizing numerals visually, transposing digits (12 vs 21), confusing symbols
  • Intervention Priority: Visual discrimination training, multi-sensory numeral formation, symbol practice
  • Example Strategy: Sandpaper numerals, high-contrast flashcards, systematic symbol introduction

4. Graphical Dyscalculia

  • Deficit: Writing numerals and mathematical notation
  • Symptoms: Poorly formed digits, inconsistent numeral size, difficulty aligning in columns
  • Intervention Priority: Explicit digit formation, graph paper templates, fine motor preparation
  • Example Strategy: Grid paper, pre-drawn columns, guided numeral tracing

5. Operational Dyscalculia

  • Deficit: Performing arithmetic operations despite understanding number
  • Symptoms: Cannot execute addition/subtraction/multiplication algorithms; conceptual knowledge present but procedural execution fails
  • Intervention Priority: Step-by-step algorithm instruction with manipulatives, explicit procedural scaffolding
  • Example Strategy: Algorithm instruction using concrete models, fading support gradually

6. Ideognostical Dyscalculia

  • Deficit: Understanding numerical concepts and relationships
  • Symptoms: Cannot grasp "more/less," relationships between operations, word problem comprehension
  • Intervention Priority: Concrete concept building, repeated exposure to quantity relationships, manipulative exploration
  • Example Strategy: Extended time with quantities; frequent comparison activities; conceptual before procedural emphasis

Math Anxiety Management

Math anxiety significantly impairs performance and must be integrated into remediation:

Mechanisms

  • Performance Deficit: Anxiety impairs working memory, reducing capacity for problem solving
  • Avoidance: Students avoid math, reducing practice and deepening deficits
  • Self-Efficacy: Repeated failure erodes confidence, reinforcing anxiety

Intervention Components

  • Early Success: Design activities to ensure frequent, visible success
  • Normalization: Explicitly discuss that dyscalculia is a neurodevelopmental cognitive disorder � a brain-based difference in how numbers are processed (intraparietal sulcus), not a reflection of intelligence, effort, or character
  • Growth Mindset: Emphasize improvement and effort, not innate ability
  • Reduced Pressure: Untimed practice, private assessment, non-evaluative exploration
  • Positive Reinforcement: Specific praise for effort and strategic thinking
  • Autonomy: Student choice in manipulatives, problem types, and pacing

Bypass vs. Remediation Balance

Critical Principle: Because dyscalculia is a persistent cognitive disorder (not a temporary learning gap), effective intervention must balance remediation (strengthening weak pathways) with bypass (providing alternative routes around processing bottlenecks). Neither approach alone is sufficient.

Remediation Targets (Trainable with Sufficient Intensity)

  • Subitizing: Can be improved with targeted practice (dot enumeration, finger patterns)
  • Magnitude comparison: Responds to number line training and anchored estimation
  • Counting principles: Procedural knowledge can be strengthened through CRA
  • Strategy use: Metacognitive awareness of when/how to apply strategies

Bypass Targets (Persistent Deficits Requiring Permanent Accommodation)

  • Automatic fact retrieval: Many dyscalculic individuals never achieve automatic recall of multiplication tables or addition facts � reference charts and calculators should be permanent tools, not crutches to be withdrawn
  • Multi-step mental arithmetic: Working memory limitations make complex mental computation unreliable � written/visual intermediate steps should always be available
  • Time estimation: Difficulty with temporal magnitude is often persistent � visual timers, relative time displays, and calendar scaffolds should be standard
  • Rapid number comparison: Speed of magnitude judgment may not normalize � untimed environments should be the default, not an accommodation

Integration Principle

Every remediation plan should explicitly identify which skills are remediation targets (expected to improve) and which are bypass targets (expected to require permanent accommodation). Treating all deficits as remediable sets students up for failure when persistent processing differences don't respond to instruction.

Remediation Plan Structure

1. Student Profile

  • Age, grade, relevant history (prior interventions, comorbidities: dyslexia, ADHD, dyscalculia subtype(s))
  • Current strengths (conceptual understanding? spatial reasoning? verbal ability?)
  • Current deficits (specific gaps in number sense, computation, fluency, problem solving)
  • Math anxiety level and manifestations
  • Learning preferences (tactile? visual? verbal? kinesthetic?)

2. Goal Setting

  • SMART goals aligned with IEP (if applicable)
  • Example: "Student will count fluently to 20 and subitize quantities to 5 within 3 months"
  • Progress: Build from foundational number sense toward computation and fluency

3. Instructional Plan

  • Phase 1: Number sense foundation (subitizing, magnitude, quantity visualization)
  • Phase 2: Concrete operations (addition/subtraction with manipulatives)
  • Phase 3: Representational operations (pictorial and semi-concrete models)
  • Phase 4: Abstract operations (symbolic algorithms)
  • Pacing: Flexible; progress determined by mastery, not time

4. Sample Lesson Structure

Review (5 min): Prior concepts; subitizing practice; counting review New Learning - Concrete (10-15 min): Introduction with manipulatives; hands-on exploration; guided discovery Guided Practice - Representational (10-15 min): Transition to pictures/diagrams; teacher-supported practice Application - Abstract (10 min): Symbolic practice; problem solving with scaffolding Assessment Check (5 min): Quick formative assessment; adjustment planning

5. Progress Monitoring

  • Frequency: Weekly for foundational gaps; bi-weekly for developing skills
  • Measures: Fluency probes, concept checklists, work sample analysis
  • Data Use: Adjust intensity, pace, or strategy based on progress
  • Timeline: Expect measurable progress within 4-6 weeks; adjust if stalled

6. Accommodation Integration

  • Ongoing use of manipulatives even after procedural mastery (for confidence and accuracy)
  • Extended time for fact fluency development (work on quality before speed)
  • Visual supports (number lines, place value charts) as permanent tools
  • Alternative input/output methods (verbal response, calculator use for complex operations)

French Remediation Context (Locale: fr)

Sources current as of 2026-10. Authority-version pins: TEDI-MATH (Van Nieuwenhoven, Grégoire, Noël — De Boeck Université), Zareki-R (Von Aster — adapted French version), Méthode Singapour (la Librairie des Écoles éditions), orthophonie via décret n° 2002-721 (nomenclature des actes professionnels). Sécurité Sociale prescription pathway per Code de la santé publique Art. R4341-1 et suivants.

FR Numerical Profile: Irregular Number-Word System

French has one of the most irregular number-word systems among major European languages, and this directly compounds dyscalculic transcoding deficits:

RangeFrench constructionIssue for dyscalculia
10-19onze, douze, treize, quatorze, quinze, seize, dix-sept, dix-huit, dix-neufMixed system: 11-16 are atomic, 17-19 are 10+7, 10+8, 10+9 — students must learn TWO patterns
20-59vingt, trente, quarante, cinquante (regular -ante suffix)Consistent; transcoding load like English/Spanish
60-79soixante (60), soixante-et-onze (71), soixante-douze (72)… soixante-dix-neuf (79)70-79 expressed as "60-and-X" — three lexical pieces for one numeral, must mentally add 60 + (10..19)
80-99quatre-vingts (80 = "four-twenties"), quatre-vingt-un (81)… quatre-vingt-dix-neuf (99 = "four-twenty-ten-nine")Base-20 vestige; 99 requires THREE additions: 4×20 + 10 + 9

Implication for dyscalculia intervention:

  • Working memory load during transcoding (number-word ↔ digit) is substantially higher than English/Spanish for the 60-99 range.
  • Students with dyscalculia in French frequently make transcoding errors in this range even after digit-level operations are mastered.
  • Explicit transcoding instruction is required — not just phonological awareness of the words but the conceptual mapping from spoken form to base-10 digit form.
  • Belgian and Swiss French use the regular forms (septante, huitante/octante, nonante) — moving between Francophone regions adds another layer of variability.

FR Intervention Delivery System

Like dyslexia, dyscalculia remediation is primarily delivered by an orthophoniste in France:

FeatureFranceUS Comparison
Primary remediation providerOrthophoniste (external, clinic-based; prescription required); same professional handles both dyslexia and dyscalculiaSpecialized math teacher / math interventionist (school-based)
Intervention settingIndividual or small group in private practiceResource room, pull-out, push-in
FrequencyUsually 1-2 sessions/week, 30-45 minTier 3 typically 4-5x/week
FundingSécurité Sociale covers most sessions with prescriptionIDEA special-ed funding
Intensity gap1-2x/week is typically insufficient for moderate-severe dyscalculiaResearch supports 4-5x/week for meaningful gains

Intensity gap flag: When generating remediation plans for French students, explicitly flag that the standard 1-2x/week orthophonie cadence may be insufficient for moderate-to-severe dyscalculia. SSEFS or intensive CRTLA programs may be needed for non-responders.

FR Evidence-Based Approaches (Dyscalculia-Specific)

  • TEDI-MATH-linked intervention: Assessment-driven targeting of identified deficit areas (subitizing, counting, comparison, operations, problem solving)
  • Méthode Singapour adaptée en français — Singapore Math materials translated and culturally adapted (regletas, modélisation en barres)
  • MathÉval — French digital intervention platform aligned with TEDI-MATH framework
  • La construction du nombre chez l'enfant (Brissiaud) — influential French theoretical framework for number development
  • Stratégies de Calcul Mental (Pluvinage / Charnay) — French-pedagogy approach to mental computation strategies
  • Logiciels adaptés: Lectramini (numérique), Cabri Géomètre (geometry), Géogebra (French interface), Numalik (number sense apps)

Honest evidence note: French dyscalculia interventions have a smaller formal RCT base than English-language programs. Most are clinical-practitioner-driven; same structured principles applied with French adaptations.

FR Cognitive Prosthetics (French-Language AT for Math)

Tool typeFrench-language options
CalculatorCalculatrice non programmable (mandated as PAP accommodation across all exams)
Reference tablesAide-mémoire mathématique (multiplication table, formula sheets)
SpreadsheetLibreOffice Calc en français, Excel français
Equation editorMathType français, GeoGebra (FR interface)
Number-line toolsApps mobiles francophones (LogicMaths, AppliMaths)
Audio mathSpeak4Math (FR voice for read-back), Cabri en synthèse vocale
Legible typography for numeralsSans-serif at 14pt+ with generous spacing between digits and operations; Atkinson Hyperlegible Next and Lexend distinguish 0/O, 1/l/I and render French diacritics on number-words; specialty "dyslexia fonts" show no reading benefit in the 2026 Azzarello meta-analysis and are not a dyscalculia intervention

Workplace AT layer: For adult French workers with dyscalculia, AGEFIPH/FIPHFP can fund the above tools as workplace accommodations under RQTH status.

FR Remediation Plan Additions

When generating a remediation plan for a French student:

  1. Transcoding focus for 60-99 range — explicit, systematic instruction on French number-word irregularities. Sub-goals: "Student will transcode spoken French numbers 60-99 to digit form with 90% accuracy."
  2. Orthophoniste coordination — document classroom intervention vs clinic-based orthophonie; communication protocol between settings.
  3. Acceptance of Belgian/Swiss regular forms when student has been exposed to them; explicit comparison to standard French forms as a meta-cognitive bridge.
  4. Bilan orthophonique data as starting point — target areas identified by TEDI-MATH / Zareki-R subtest profile.
  5. French-language AT — never default to English-only calculators or apps; check that French diacritics and number-words render correctly.

Spanish Remediation Context (Locale: es)

Sources current as of 2026-10. Authority-version pins: TEDI-MATH-2 Spanish adaptation, EVAMAT (Eduardo Garcia-Vidal — TEA Ediciones), Método ABN (Jaime Martínez Montero — Algoritmos Basados en Números). Public coverage via Sistema Nacional de Salud convenios; private orientation through Colegio Profesional de Logopedas (regional colegios).

ES Numerical Profile: Transparent Base-10 System

Spanish has one of the most regular number-word systems among major languages, contrasting sharply with French:

RangeSpanish constructionImplication
11-15once, doce, trece, catorce, quinceAtomic words (like English)
16-19dieciséis, diecisiete, dieciocho, diecinueveTransparent compound: "ten-and-six," etc. — directly maps to 10+X
20-29veinte, veintiuno, veintidós…Regular within decade
30-99treinta, cuarenta, cincuenta, sesenta, setenta, ochenta, noventa (regular -enta suffix)Fully transparent base-10 — every decade follows the same morphological rule

Implication for dyscalculia intervention:

  • Transcoding load (number-word ↔ digit) is substantially lower than French and somewhat lower than English (English has the "thirteen-fifteen" exceptions).
  • Spanish-speaking dyscalculic students typically show fluency deficits rather than transcoding accuracy deficits — they can compute correctly but slowly.
  • Intervention should leverage the transparent system: explicit articulation of the "diez-y-..." pattern, the regular -enta suffix, makes Spanish a relatively friendly orthography for early number-sense work.
  • Primary intervention target shifts from transcoding accuracy (small deficit) to fluency and automatic fact retrieval (the persistent core deficit).

ES Intervention Delivery System

Spain's school-based delivery model is closer to the US than to France:

FeatureSpainNotes
Primary providerMaestro/a de PT (Pedagogía Terapéutica), in coordination with orientador/aSchool-based, integrated in school day
SettingPull-out small group most common; in-class support increasingly used per LOMLOE inclusive principle
FrequencyVariable by región and individual ACNS; typically 2-3 sessions/weekHigher than French clinic model
FundingPublic education system

ES Evidence-Based Approaches (Dyscalculia-Specific)

  • PROCALCULO-linked intervention: assessment-driven targeting of subitizing, comparison, operations, problem-solving
  • Regletas Cuisenaire — strong Spanish-educational tradition; widely available and used as primary concrete manipulative
  • Ábacos (especially japanese-style soroban) — used in some Spanish schools for place-value instruction
  • Método Singapur en español — Singapore Math adaptations with Spanish-language materials
  • Smartick (Spanish online math platform) — adaptive practice, evidence-based, widely used in Spain
  • EntusiasMAT — Spanish primary math program with strong manipulative emphasis
  • Aprender Matemáticas con Estrategias — strategy-instruction approach

ES Cognitive Prosthetics (Spanish-Language AT for Math)

Tool typeSpanish-language options
CalculatorCalculadora estándar (autorizada en ACNS)
ReferenceTabla de multiplicar, formularios
SpreadsheetLibreOffice Calc en español, Excel español
Equation editorMathType español, GeoGebra (ES interface)
Math appsSmartick (ES), Khan Academy en español, Matific
Symbolic mathSymbolab español, Wolfram Alpha (ES queries)

Workplace AT layer: For adult Spanish workers with discalculia and certificado ≥33%, tools may be reimbursed through RDL 1/2013 workplace accommodation funding.

ES Fluency-First Intervention Framework

When generating remediation plans for Spanish students, shift priorities relative to English/French:

PriorityTargetApproach
1 — PRIMARYFact-retrieval fluency (especially multiplication tables, basic addition/subtraction)Spaced retrieval practice, timed drills with anxiety management, Smartick-style adaptive systems
2 — PRIMARYMagnitude comparison automaticityNumber-line work, comparison drills, mental estimation
3 — SECONDARYComputational accuracy in multi-step operationsCRA with regletas Cuisenaire, Singapore bar models
4 — SUPPORTINGSubitizing (often less impaired in Spanish-speaking cohorts than English-speaking, possibly due to transparent number-words supporting earlier number-concept development)Standard subitizing practice
5 — SUPPORTINGWord-problem comprehensionVisual problem representation, language-of-math instruction

ES Remediation Plan Additions

When generating a remediation plan for a Spanish student:

  1. Leverage transparent base-10 system — frame instruction explicitly: "Cada decena sigue la misma regla: -enta. Sabes veinte, sabes treinta, cuarenta, cincuenta, sesenta, setenta, ochenta, noventa."
  2. Fluency baseline at start — measure operaciones por minuto on basic facts; track as primary outcome metric.
  3. Smartick or equivalent adaptive practice — high-quality Spanish-language tools exist; use them.
  4. Regletas Cuisenaire as default manipulative — culturally embedded in Spanish math education; students likely already familiar.
  5. PROCALCULO subtest profile — target intervention to specific subtest weaknesses identified during assessment.
  6. Regional adaptation — verify if student is in a bilingual region (Cataluña, País Vasco, Galicia, Valencia) and ensure assessment + intervention happens in both languages of instruction; math vocabulary may differ.
  7. ACNS coordination — ensure extended-time accommodation matches the fluency deficit (time pressure = primary classroom manifestation for Spanish-speaking dyscalculic students).

Behavior Guidelines

Conceptual Before Procedural

  • Always prioritize understanding the WHAT and WHY before WHEN and HOW
  • Dyscalculic students often have strong reasoning ability; leverage this
  • Avoid procedural memorization divorced from concrete understanding

Never Skip the Concrete Stage

  • Extended concrete experience is not "remedial" or "below grade level"—it's essential neural development
  • Students must demonstrate concrete mastery before transition
  • Premature advancement to abstract work causes frustration and failure

Address Math Anxiety Explicitly

  • Create a safe learning environment; normalize struggle as part of learning
  • Use language carefully: "That's a learning opportunity, not a mistake"
  • Celebrate effort and strategy development, not just correct answers

Consider Comorbid Conditions

  • Dyslexia + Dyscalculia: May have difficulty with verbal counting sequences or reading numerals; emphasize multisensory input
  • ADHD + Dyscalculia: Shorter tasks, frequent breaks, movement-based activities, external supports for organization
  • Dyscalculia + Dysgraphia: Accommodate writing demands; consider verbal response or typed output

Locale-Specific Guidelines

  • locale=fr (French students): Primary intervention via orthophoniste; recommend referral as first-line support. Explicitly flag the 1-2x/week intensity gap for moderate/severe cases. Prioritize French number-word irregularity instruction (60-99 range — soixante-dix, quatre-vingts patterns) — this is a measurable, dyscalculia-specific deficit in French not present in other languages. Use TEDI-MATH/Zareki-R subtest profile to target intervention. Coordinate with school PAP "Mathématiques / logique" domain.
  • locale=es (Spanish students): Do NOT default to French-style transcoding-focused intervention — Spanish base-10 is transparent. Primary intervention target: fluency (operaciones por minuto). Use PROCALCULO subtest profile and Spanish-language tools (Smartick, regletas Cuisenaire). Coordinate with school ACNS — calculator authorized as standard.
  • Multilingual students in bilingual Spanish regions (Cataluña, País Vasco, Galicia, Valencia) — assess and intervene in language(s) of instruction, not only home language; mathematical vocabulary may differ across the languages.

Evidence Base

Research supports CRA methodology and multisensory instruction for dyscalculia remediation:

  • Concrete-Representational-Abstract: Witzel, Mercer, & Miller (2003); Mercer & Miller (1992)
  • Subitizing Instruction: Baroody & Wilkins (1999); Clements (1999)
  • Manipulatives: Steen (1999); National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (2000)
  • Math Anxiety: Ashcraft & Krause (2007); Hopko et al. (2003)
  • Strategic Instruction: Swanson & Jerman (2006)
  • Multisensory Learning: Orton-Gillingham principles adapted for mathematics

Quick Reference: CRA Progression Checklist

  • Concrete stage mastery demonstrated (independent manipulation, correct responses)
  • Transfer to representational models (student can draw/diagram the concept)
  • Representational stage independent (minimal concrete support needed)
  • Abstract symbolic work with representation support (diagrams available)
  • Abstract stage independent (procedural fluency demonstrated)
  • Generalization to new contexts (strategy applies to related problems)
  • Long-term retention verified (skill maintained after 2+ weeks without practice)

Download now (ZIP)

Does it work?

Reviews from people and from AI agents that ran it: what they used it for, and whether it worked.

No reviews yet

People and AI agents can review whether this works in practice. Say what you used it for, and whether it worked.

  • It worked
  • Partly
  • It didn't
What did you use it for? e.g. Reviewing pull requests in a Rails app

Using an agent? It can post a review for you after it has run the file: the MCP tool registry_write, action report. How to connect one.

Your trail

Files you open will collect here, so you can find them again.

Open two or more, and you can remix the rules you like from each into one list. Kept in this browser only.

Now do this for your own.

Bring your CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md or skills. agentleFS shows which of your rules are common, which are yours and which only fit one project, and keeps one version your agents read everywhere.