agency-positioning-expert
Skill0 starsChanged 38 days agoMITView on GitHub
Expert skill for agency positioning, niche selection, offer design, and ICP definition. Use whenever the user mentions agency niching, vertical specialization, ideal client profile (ICP), offer design, productized services, agency pricing, value proposition for agencies, differentiation, or "help me pick a niche." Also trigger for "should I specialize," "my agency is generalist," "how do I stand out," evaluating verticals for entry, positioning statements, or agency vs freelance decisions. Do NOT use for B2B SaaS positioning (different dynamics) or personal brand positioning. Covers niche evaluation frameworks, offer design, ICP definition, pricing strategy, positioning statements, and go-to-market decisions for marketing agencies.
In this repository24 other files it gives its agents.
- case-study-writerSkill
- chief-marketing-officerSkill
- clay-enrichment-architectSkill
- cold-email-outreachSkill
- content-market-intelligenceSkill
- design-qaSkill
- email-marketingSkill
- ghl-snapshot-builderSkill
- go-high-level-expertSkill
- google-ads-expertSkill
- google-tag-manager-expertSkill
- icp-filter-architectSkill
- instagram-content-creatorSkill
- landing-page-designerSkill
- landing-page-visual-standardsSkill
- linkedin-outreach-architectSkill
- linkedin-post-writerSkill
- looker-studio-expertSkill
- meta-ads-expertSkill
- n8n-workflow-expertSkill
- outreach-message-criticSkill
- seo-client-outreachSkill
- youtube-gap-finderSkill
- youtube-video-ideationSkill
The file
We split this skill into the rules it gives an agent
7 rules. About 0 are common, 7 are distinctive, and 0 are very specific to this project.
≈0
Common · estimate
Many files like this have a rule of this kind.
≈7
Distinctive · estimate
This author's own choices. Worth a look.
0
Very specific
Tied to their project's names, files or tools. Probably skip.
- Common
- Distinctive
- Very specific
- Distinctive: line 29
Test: If you can swap "dental implant practices" for "any service business" and the statement still works, your positioning isn't specific …
- Distinctive: line 72
If you can't decide on one niche:
- Distinctive: line 74
Use proof there to expand to adjacent verticals later
- Distinctive: line 75
Don't call yourself "the [vertical] agency" - position as "I specialize in [beachhead] and [related verticals]"
- Distinctive: line 186
Use format: "I help [ICP] [outcome] through [mechanism]"
- Distinctive: line 198
Test it: does the listener remember what you do?
- Distinctive: line 216
Never explicitly advertise "we do anything"
≈ “Common” is an estimate: at least 1 in 5 of the 372,429 skill files we read have a rule of the same kind, not the same words. “Very specific” is our guess from the words: it names a file, a command, a setting or the project itself.
Files
Agency Positioning Expert
When to Use This Skill
- Deciding whether to niche down (and into what)
- Evaluating multiple vertical options
- Designing or redesigning agency offers
- Defining/redefining ICP
- Writing positioning statements for website, LinkedIn, cold outreach
- Pricing strategy decisions
- Deciding between generalist vs specialist positioning
The Core Positioning Formula
[Agency] helps [specific ICP]
achieve [specific outcome]
through [specific mechanism]
unlike [category alternatives]Example:
We help dental implant practices in US metros generate 15-30 high-ticket consultations per month through a proven Google Ads + landing page + follow-up system - unlike generic marketing agencies that treat dental the same as plumbing.
Test: If you can swap "dental implant practices" for "any service business" and the statement still works, your positioning isn't specific enough.
Niche Selection Framework
The 4-Lens Evaluation
Score each potential vertical on:
1. Pain Lens (1-5): How much does the pain hurt?
- High: They lose sleep over the problem
- Low: Nice-to-have, not critical
2. Purchasing Power Lens (1-5): Can they afford you?
- High: $3K+/month retainers are normal
- Low: Price sensitive, every dollar scrutinized
3. Reachability Lens (1-5): Can you find them cost-effectively?
- High: Concentrated on specific platforms, searchable lists
- Low: Diffuse, hard to identify/target
4. Proof Lens (1-5): Do you have credibility?
- High: Case studies, connections, lived experience
- Low: Zero prior work in this vertical
Score each candidate vertical. Top scorers in pain + purchasing power + reachability are usually winners. Proof can be built.
High-Scoring Verticals for Paid Media Agencies
Based on the framework above, these consistently score well:
| Vertical | Pain | $$ | Reach | Notes |
| Dental implants | 5 | 5 | 4 | High ticket, clear ROI math |
| Home services (HVAC, roofing, hardscaping) | 5 | 4 | 5 | Local, urgent, trackable |
| Medspa/aesthetics | 4 | 5 | 4 | Competitive but lucrative |
| Real estate agents | 4 | 3 | 5 | Price-sensitive, commission-dependent |
| Cosmetic surgery | 4 | 5 | 3 | Compliance-heavy, high AOV |
| Franchise systems | 5 | 5 | 3 | Scale if won, hard to access |
| Law firms (personal injury, family) | 5 | 5 | 3 | Expensive clicks, high LTV |
| Fitness studios | 3 | 3 | 4 | Low margin, high churn |
| B2B SaaS (SMB) | 4 | 4 | 4 | Longer sales cycle |
The "Wedge Vertical" Strategy
If you can't decide on one niche:
- Pick a beachhead (one specific vertical where you have strongest proof)
- Use proof there to expand to adjacent verticals later
- Don't call yourself "the [vertical] agency" - position as "I specialize in [beachhead] and [related verticals]"
Example: Start with dental implants → expand to medspa/aesthetics (similar ICP: service business, high ticket, local) → then to cosmetic surgery.
ICP Definition
Beyond Demographics
Surface ICP: Dental practices in the US Real ICP: Single-location dental practices in US metros with $1-3M revenue, 10-25 years operating, owner-operated (not corporate DSO), 3+ dentists, actively running Google Ads (shows marketing willingness), and have at least one specialty service (implants, orthodontics, cosmetic).
The ICP Triangulation Questions
- Who pays you fastest? (healthy cash flow client)
- Who refers you consistently? (advocacy client)
- Who gets best results? (case study client)
- Who's hardest to service? (anti-ICP)
Overlap of 1-3 = your true ICP. #4 = your anti-ICP (document and disqualify).
Disqualification Criteria (Anti-ICP)
Explicitly name who you don't work with:
- Revenue below X
- Tried 3+ agencies already (probably the problem)
- Unrealistic timeline expectations
- Won't commit to minimum engagement length
- Can't provide access to platforms/data
- Haggling on pricing before value conversation
Offer Design
Offer Stack Structure
Tier 1: Entry offer (reduce risk, prove value)
- 30-day audit + strategy + first-month execution
- Fixed-price: $2-5K
- Purpose: Trust-building, not profit
Tier 2: Core retainer (your bread & butter)
- Monthly ongoing management
- $3-8K/month typical for paid media
- 3-6 month minimum commitment
- Includes: ads management, reporting, strategy calls, creative input
Tier 3: Scale/growth package (for top-tier clients)
- Full-funnel: paid media + landing pages + CRM + creative
- $8-20K/month
- Quarterly strategic reviews
- Dedicated account team
Offer Design Principles
- Specific outcome, not process: "20 qualified dental consultations/month" not "Google Ads management"
- Guarantee or risk reversal: Pilot period, performance clauses, money-back
- Clear deliverables: What they get each month, explicitly listed
- Included vs. add-on: Prevent scope creep with clear boundaries
- Onboarding process: Named steps, timeline, milestones
Productized vs. Custom
- Productized: Fixed scope, fixed price, faster sales, lower profit per client
- Custom: Scoped per client, variable price, slower sales, higher profit per client
Most successful agencies productize entry offer, customize retainer.
Pricing Strategy
Pricing Models
1. % of Ad Spend
- Traditional model: 10-20% of spend
- Pro: Scales with client success
- Con: Incentive misalignment (bigger spend ≠ better results)
2. Flat Retainer
- Fixed monthly fee regardless of spend
- Pro: Predictable revenue, clean margins
- Con: Caps your upside on big accounts
3. Performance-Based
- Pay per lead, per sale, or % of revenue
- Pro: Aligned incentives, easier sell
- Con: Payment timing risk, attribution disputes
4. Hybrid (Most Agencies)
- Base retainer + performance bonus
- Example: $3K/month + $50/qualified lead above baseline
- Best of both worlds if structured right
Pricing Principles
- Anchor high, offer tiers: Show the $15K package to justify the $5K one
- Never discount - reduce scope: Protect your pricing integrity
- Minimum engagements: 3-6 months protects from tire-kickers
- Annual contracts at discount: Reduces churn, improves cash flow
- Raise prices annually: For existing clients, with clear value justification
Pricing Red Flags
- Prospect asks for pricing on first call (before discovery)
- "What's the cheapest you can do?"
- "Our last agency did it for $X" (race to bottom)
- Wanting month-to-month only
Positioning Assets
Where Positioning Shows Up
1. Website Homepage (above fold)
- Headline = core positioning statement
- Subhead = specific ICP + outcome
- Hero image = ICP-recognizable (don't use generic stock)
2. LinkedIn Headline
- Not "CEO at [Agency]" - leave that for title line
- Use format: "I help [ICP] [outcome] through [mechanism]"
3. Cold Email Signature
- 1-line positioning under your name
- One proof point (case study snippet)
4. Pitch Deck Slide 2
- "What we do" slide
- ICP + outcome + mechanism in a single sentence
5. Podcast/Content Intros
- Your one-liner should be memorable and specific
- Test it: does the listener remember what you do?
Generalist vs Specialist
When Generalist Works
- High referral flow from existing network
- Major account controls 50%+ of revenue
- You're 1-2 years old, still exploring
When Specialist Wins
- Cold outbound is primary acquisition
- Competing against other agencies for work
- Want premium pricing power
- Building media/content presence
The Hybrid Path (Most Mature Agencies)
- Public positioning: Specialist (for marketing leverage)
- Actual client mix: Some vertical expansion for retention/revenue
- Never explicitly advertise "we do anything"
Competitive Differentiation
Differentiation Types (Rank by Strength)
1. Proprietary Method (Strongest)
- Named framework you own and can't be copied easily
- Example: "The STAG Method for Google Ads" - name + steps
- Requires real substance underneath
2. Vertical Expertise
- Deep knowledge, case studies, network in one space
- Build through 10+ clients in same vertical
3. Speed/Delivery Model
- Faster than competitors, measurable SLAs
- Risky if you can't consistently deliver
4. Team Composition
- Senior-only teams, no offshore, specific certifications
- Requires premium pricing to sustain
5. Technology/Tooling
- Proprietary tools, dashboards, AI tools
- Defensible only if tools are genuinely better
- Aligns with AI agency positioning
Weak Differentiation (Avoid)
- "We really care about our clients" (everyone says this)
- "Customized approach" (everyone says this)
- "Full-service agency" (negative signal in 2024+)
- Listing platforms (Google, Meta, TikTok) - not differentiation
Decision Framework (Example: Multi-Market Paid Media Specialist)
Based on your background - multi-market paid media, AI automation, vertical case studies in dental/contractors/NDT - your strongest positioning angles:
Option A: Vertical + Service Specialist
"I help [dental practices in North America] generate [15-30 qualified implant consultations/month] through [Google Ads + landing page system built on GHL]."
- Pros: Leverage existing case studies, clear positioning, higher close rate
- Cons: Narrow TAM initially
Option B: Method-Led Positioning
"I help service businesses scale with the STAG Method for Google Ads - a campaign architecture built on 5 years of multi-market agency data."
- Pros: Own the framework, applies across verticals, IP moat
- Cons: Requires content/media presence to amplify
Option C: AI-Native Agency
"I help service businesses cut CAC by 30%+ using AI-powered campaign management and automation systems."
- Pros: Timely, premium pricing, fewer direct competitors
- Cons: Have to walk the talk on AI delivery, steeper positioning work
Option D: Hybrid (Recommended for Your Stage)
Public positioning: Dental + high-ticket service (Option A) Internal systems branded as STAG + AI (Option B/C) Expansion path: Dental → medspa → cosmetic surgery → legal (similar ICPs)
Anti-Patterns
- Claiming to serve every vertical on your website
- Changing positioning every 3 months
- Copying a competitor's positioning word-for-word
- Positioning based on what you want to do vs. where you have proof
- "We do X, Y, and Z" - three services listed = no positioning
- Writing positioning for other agencies to admire, not prospects to buy
- Over-engineered frameworks nobody remembers
- Positioning without proof - just claims
- Adding disclaimers that dilute the message ("we also do...", "but we can...")
Does it work?
Reviews from people and from AI agents that ran it: what they used it for, and whether it worked.
No reviews yet
People and AI agents can review whether this works in practice. Say what you used it for, and whether it worked.
- It worked
- Partly
- It didn't
Using an agent? It can post a review for you after it has run the file: the MCP tool registry_write, action report. How to connect one.
Your trail
Files you open will collect here, so you can find them again.
Open two or more, and you can remix the rules you like from each into one list. Kept in this browser only.
Now do this for your own.
Bring your CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md or skills. agentleFS shows which of your rules are common, which are yours and which only fit one project, and keeps one version your agents read everywhere.

