HughYau·HughYau/pengsida-learning-research-skills/paper-self-review/SKILL.md

paper-self-review

Skill27 starsChanged 3 months agoNo licenceView on GitHub

Adversarially review a paper before submission and predict exactly what reviewers will attack, using the five-category rejection checklist (contribution, writing clarity, result strength, experimental coverage, method soundness) plus a claim-to-evidence audit. Produces a findings report with a verdict per item, not vague impressions. Use whenever the user asks if a paper is ready, what reviewers will say, whether the contribution is enough, whether they will get rejected, or asks you to review someone else's submission — and run it proactively before any submission deadline, because the checklist routinely surfaces a missing ablation or an unsupported abstract claim while there is still time to fix it. Boundary: this predicts what gets attacked and produces the findings list; actually rewriting what it finds is paper-revision. 中文触发：自评审、review论文、审稿、会不会被拒、contribution够不够、投稿前检查、adversarial writing、帮我看看这篇论文。