HughYau·HughYau/pengsida-learning-research-skills/paper-revision/SKILL.md

paper-revision

Skill27 starsChanged 3 months agoNo licenceView on GitHub

Revise paper text in response to criticism — your own, an advisor's, or a reviewer's. Two halves that share one discipline: (1) fixing prose by encoding it back into a high-level outline, locating where the logic is missing or jumps, fixing it there, then decoding to English again, plus the sentence-flow test and paragraph-clarity checks; (2) writing a rebuttal, which first answers why each reviewer gave that score, classifies every concern into answerable-from-existing-content / needs-new-experiment / misunderstanding / genuine-limitation, then drafts per reviewer section in their own question order. Use whenever the user pastes text to improve, says the writing is unclear or doesn't flow, is working through comments on a draft, mentions receiving reviews or scores, or asks how to answer a weakness — and resist polishing sentences directly, because smooth prose over a broken outline is the hardest failure to detect later. Boundary: this fixes text that exists; if the question is whether the paper will survive review at all rather than whether a passage is clear, that is paper-self-review. 中文触发：改论文、改写作、这段写得清楚吗、句子不通顺、flow、润色、逻辑不连贯、reverse outline、rebuttal、回复审稿意见、收到review了、weakness怎么答、提分。