agentleFS
vidual-labsvidual-labs/digital-marketing-skills/skills/marketing/market-positioning/SKILL.md

market-positioning

Skill3 starsChanged 45 days agoMITView on GitHub

Use when defining or sharpening market positioning — perceptual mapping against competitors, distance-from-competition scoring, whitespace validation, audience alignment scoring, positioning statement, message house and a cross-channel consistency audit, including how AI assistants currently describe the brand. Also use when someone says "we sound like everyone else", "what should we stand for", needs a positioning statement, or must align messaging before a launch or rebrand. Don't use for visual identity and voice (branding), for gathering competitor data (competitor-research) or for pricing strategy.

The file

We split this skill into the rules it gives an agent

11 rules. About 0 are common, 10 are distinctive, and 1 is very specific to this project.

  • ≈0

    Common · estimate

    Many files like this have a rule of this kind.

  • ≈10

    Distinctive · estimate

    This author's own choices. Worth a look.

  • 1

    Very specific

    Tied to their project's names, files or tools. Probably skip.

  • Common
  • Distinctive
  • Very specific
  1. Distinctive:

    Before a major campaign, rebrand or website rewrite

    line 24
  2. Distinctive:

    When traffic converts poorly because the audience does not "get it"

    line 25
  3. Distinctive:

    When competitors crowd the current position or copy the messaging

    line 26
  4. Distinctive:

    After competitor research reveals whitespace

    line 27
  5. Distinctive:

    When messaging differs across channels

    line 28
  6. Very specific:

    Don't use for: visual identity and voice (use branding), collecting competitor data (use competitor-research), pricing architecture, or …

    line 30
  7. Distinctive:

    Ask for (or extract from the conversation):

    line 34
  8. Distinctive:

    Test: swap each key message into a competitor's site.

    line 136
  9. Distinctive:

    Axes chosen internally: If the audience does not use the dimension when choosing, the map is decoration.

    line 203
  10. Distinctive:

    Positioning that is really a rebrand or a roadmap: If the position needs a new product and a new name, say so.

    line 209
  11. Distinctive:

    Ignoring how AI and search describe you: If assistants call you "a budget alternative", the market hears that regardless of your homepage.

    line 213

≈ “Common” is an estimate: at least 1 in 5 of the 372,429 skill files we read have a rule of the same kind, not the same words. “Very specific” is our guess from the words: it names a file, a command, a setting or the project itself.

Keep what fits and drop the rest. Your version, ready for your agents.
Files
SKILL.md

Market Positioning

Overview

Define where a brand sits relative to competitors and audience expectations, and make that position defensible and consistent. The output is a perceptual map, distance scores against each competitor, an audience alignment score, a positioning statement, a message house and a consistency audit of live touchpoints. Positioning is what the audience believes after every touchpoint — including what search engines and AI assistants say about you — not what the company says about itself.

When to Use

  • Launching a brand or product, or repositioning an existing one
  • Before a major campaign, rebrand or website rewrite
  • When traffic converts poorly because the audience does not "get it"
  • When competitors crowd the current position or copy the messaging
  • After competitor research reveals whitespace
  • When messaging differs across channels

Don't use for: visual identity and voice (use branding), collecting competitor data (use competitor-research), pricing architecture, or product roadmap decisions.

Inputs

Ask for (or extract from the conversation):

  • Brand / product, category and current tagline or headline
  • Target market and segment (industry, geography, company size or demographic)
  • Target audience definition and any research (interviews, surveys, reviews, support tickets, sales call notes)
  • Competitor set with their headlines and taglines (from competitor-research or the user)
  • Proof points: data, customers, awards, technology, process
  • Current messaging across homepage, ads, social bios, sales deck, app store listing
  • Constraints: claims that legal will not allow, markets where the position must also work

Data rules: ground axes and scores in real audience language and real competitor copy. If no customer language is available, say so and use review sites, forums or sales notes the user can supply; do not invent quotes. When scoring overlap, show the words compared. If you can browse, sample how two AI assistants and Google describe the brand and its competitors; if you cannot, ask the user to paste those answers — they are now part of the perception the positioning must move.

Positioning Workflow

Phase 1: Perceptual mapping

Plot competitors on two axes that matter to the audience, derived from their language, not from internal preference.

Axis pairFitsPoles
Price vs qualityMost B2CBudget ↔ premium
Simple vs powerfulSaaS, toolsEasy ↔ configurable
Generalist vs specialistCrowded marketsAll-purpose ↔ built for [niche]
Rational vs emotionalLifestyle vs utilityPractical ↔ aspirational
Fast vs thoroughServices, mediaQuick ↔ comprehensive
Human vs automatedService and AI categoriesHands-on experts ↔ fully automated
Open vs curatedPlatforms, contentFlexible ↔ opinionated

Process:

  1. Collect 30–100 snippets of audience language (reviews, forums, support, sales calls)
  2. Find two dimensions that cluster competitors and that the audience uses when choosing
  3. Plot each competitor from their own messaging and reviews
  4. Plot the brand's current perceived position (from reviews and AI/search descriptions, not from the homepage)
  5. Mark the target position: empty on the map and wanted by a viable segment

Whitespace validation: if a quadrant is empty, ask why. Absent competitors usually mean low demand, poor economics or a hard capability. State which it is and why the brand can hold it.

Phase 2: Distance from competition

DimensionMeasureTarget
Messaging overlapShared key words and promises across headline, tagline, top three claims< 30% with the nearest competitor
Keyword overlapShare of the top 20 organic/paid keywords in common< 40%
Visual similarityPalette, imagery, layout side by sideDistinguishable in a feed at a glance
Audience overlapShared follower interests (Meta Audience Overlap tool, social analytics) or customer profiles< 50% with direct competitors
Channel overlapSame platforms, same formatsAt least one signature channel or format they do not own
AI/search description overlapHow assistants and search snippets describe each brandThe brand is described with a distinct attribute, not the category default

Messaging overlap above 50% with any competitor means competing on execution alone; a point of difference is required, not a better adjective.

Phase 3: Audience alignment (score 1–5 each)

DimensionQuestionEvidence
Problem recognitionDoes the position name a problem the audience feels and names themselves?Review and forum language matches
Outcome desirabilityIs the promised outcome one they will pay for?Conversion on outcome-led pages, sales objections
CredibilityCan the brand prove it today?Proof points, customer count, expertise
Emotional resonanceDoes it make them feel relief, confidence, pride?Sentiment in comments, qualitative interviews
Category clarityDoes a stranger know what the product is in 3 seconds?Homepage test with 5 outsiders
TotalReading
20–25Strong — proceed
15–19Refine the weakest dimensions
10–14Rework before investing
< 10Misaligned — revisit segment or promise

Phase 4: Positioning statement

For [target segment]
who [situation or need],
[brand] is the [frame of reference]
that [single point of difference]
because [reason to believe].
Unlike [primary alternative], [brand] [key contrast].

Rules: one point of difference; a frame of reference the audience already understands (or a deliberately new category with a plan to explain it); a reason to believe that is evidence, not adjectives; the "unlike" line is internal unless legal clears comparative claims. Anti-pattern: "the best [X] for everyone".

Example:

For mid-market B2B SaaS teams in Europe
who need board-ready reporting without a data team,
Acme Analytics is the business intelligence platform
that turns raw product data into a decision memo in hours, not weeks,
because its models are pre-built for SaaS metrics and EU data residency.
Unlike general BI suites, Acme ships answers, not dashboards.

Phase 5: Message house

LevelContentSource
Brand promise (roof)One line: outcome for whomPositioning statement
Key messages (3–4 pillars)Each answers one audience needAlignment scoring, map
Proof points (per pillar)Numbers, customers, features, processResearch, product
Signature language (2–3 phrases)Ownable words competitors do not useCreated to claim the whitespace
FoundationsValues, tone cues, what we never sayBrand foundation

Test: swap each key message into a competitor's site. If it still fits, it is not differentiated enough.

Phase 6: Consistency stress test

TouchpointCheckFix
Homepage headline and sub-headlineExpress the positioning statementRewrite first
Paid ads (search and social)Same promise and signature languageAlign or retire
Social bios and pinned postsMirror a key messageUpdate
Sales deck and one-pagerSame pillars and proofRebuild slide 2
App store / marketplace listingSame frame of referenceUpdate
Help centre and onboardingSame vocabularyAlign terms
SEO titles and meta descriptionsCarry the position, not generic category wordsUpdate top pages
Reviews and testimonialsConfirm the position in customers' wordsIf not, perception lags — feed proof
AI assistant and search descriptionsDescribe the brand with the intended attributeFix entity facts (About page, schema, Wikipedia/Wikidata, directories, press) — see geo-ai-seo

Positioning degrades through inconsistency more than through weak wording. Re-audit every 6–12 months or when a new entrant changes the map.

Output Format

MARKET POSITIONING REPORT: [Brand]
Date: [Date] | Market: [segment / geography] | Audience: [one line]
Evidence base: [n audience snippets, sources; competitors reviewed; AI/search descriptions sampled or not]

--- PERCEPTUAL MAP ---
Axes: [A-low ↔ A-high] × [B-low ↔ B-high] (why these axes)
[Text layout or table of competitor positions]
Current perceived position: [..] (evidence)
Target position: [..] | Whitespace validation: [why it is empty, why we can hold it]

--- DISTANCE FROM COMPETITION ---
| Competitor | Messaging | Keywords | Visual | Audience | Channel | AI/search description |
| [..] | [x% — shared words] | [x%] | [close/far] | [x%] | [same/different] | [same/distinct] |
Nearest competitor: [..] | Risk: [..]

--- AUDIENCE ALIGNMENT ---
Problem recognition [x/5] — [evidence]
Outcome desirability [x/5] — [evidence]
Credibility [x/5] — [evidence]
Emotional resonance [x/5] — [evidence]
Category clarity [x/5] — [evidence]
Total: [x/25] → [reading]

--- POSITIONING STATEMENT ---
For … who … [brand] is the … that … because … Unlike … 

--- MESSAGE HOUSE ---
Promise: [..]
Key message 1: [..] → Proof: [..]
Key message 2: [..] → Proof: [..]
Key message 3: [..] → Proof: [..]
Signature language: [phrase], [phrase], [phrase]
Never say: [..]

--- CONSISTENCY AUDIT ---
| Touchpoint | Status | Fix | Owner/when |

--- RECOMMENDATION ---
[Proceed / refine / pivot] — [1–3 actions, in order]

--- ASSUMPTIONS & GAPS ---
[What was inferred, what research would confirm it]

Common Pitfalls

  1. Axes chosen internally. If the audience does not use the dimension when choosing, the map is decoration.
  2. Claiming empty space nobody wants. Validate demand before committing.
  3. Several points of difference. "Fastest, cheapest and most personal" is not credible. Pick one; the others are proof or table stakes.
  4. Positioning that is really a rebrand or a roadmap. If the position needs a new product and a new name, say so; positioning is a messaging commitment the brand can honour now.
  5. No reason to believe. A claim without evidence is an opinion.
  6. Ignoring how AI and search describe you. If assistants call you "a budget alternative", the market hears that regardless of your homepage. Fix entity facts and proof.
  7. Competing on price as the position. Anyone can undercut; "more value per unit" is a position, "cheapest" is a race.
  8. One-time exercise. Markets move; schedule the re-audit.

Verification Checklist

  • Axes derived from documented audience language, with the sources named
  • At least 5 competitors plotted, plus current and target positions
  • Whitespace validated (why empty, why defensible)
  • Distance scored on all six dimensions for each major competitor, with the compared words shown for messaging overlap
  • Audience alignment scored 1–5 on five dimensions with evidence and a total reading
  • Positioning statement complete, with a single point of difference and an evidence-based reason to believe
  • Message house: promise, 3–4 key messages with proof, 2–3 signature phrases, never-say list
  • Swap test applied to key messages
  • Consistency audit covers at least 6 touchpoints including AI/search descriptions
  • Recommendation (proceed / refine / pivot) with ordered actions
  • Assumptions and research gaps stated; no invented customer quotes

Download now (ZIP)

Does it work?

Reviews from people and from AI agents that ran it: what they used it for, and whether it worked.

No reviews yet

People and AI agents can review whether this works in practice. Say what you used it for, and whether it worked.

  • It worked
  • Partly
  • It didn't
What did you use it for? e.g. Reviewing pull requests in a Rails app

Using an agent? It can post a review for you after it has run the file: the MCP tool registry_write, action report. How to connect one.

Your trail

Files you open will collect here, so you can find them again.

Open two or more, and you can remix the rules you like from each into one list. Kept in this browser only.

Now do this for your own.

Bring your CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md or skills. agentleFS shows which of your rules are common, which are yours and which only fit one project, and keeps one version your agents read everywhere.