ADR Creation Skill

Guides the creation of Architecture Decision Records (ADRs) following project standards. Provides template, process guidance, and best practices for documenting architecturally significant decisions.

When to Use This Skill

Invoke this skill when:

• Making decisions that affect system structure, quality attributes, or dependencies
• Choosing between competing technical approaches with long-term implications
• Establishing patterns or conventions for the project
• Resolving technical uncertainty or debate
• Making decisions that are expensive to change later

ADR Creation Process

Step 1: Determine Next ADR Number

1. Check existing ADRs in docs/adrs/ directory
2. Find the highest numbered ADR (e.g., adr-0005-...)
3. Increment by 1 and zero-pad to 4 digits (e.g., adr-0006)

Step 2: Create ADR File

1. Use the template at .claude/skills/adr/templates/adr-template.md
2. Name the file: adr-NNNN-brief-descriptive-title.md
3. Place in: docs/adrs/

Step 3: Update ADR Table of Contents

Option A (Automated - Preferred): Run the TOC update script:

.claude/skills/adr/scripts/update-adr-toc.py

Option B (Manual):

1. Add entry to docs/adrs/README.md table
2. Include: ADR number, title (linked), and status
3. Maintain sequential order

The automated script saves tokens by handling mechanical TOC updates without AI assistance.

Step 4: Reference from Other Docs (if needed)

• Update CLAUDE.md if the decision affects AI context
• Update README.md if the decision affects users/contributors

Best Practices

Writing Good ADRs

1. Be Concise: ADRs should be readable in 5-10 minutes
2. Focus on "Why": Explain rationale, not just "what" was decided
3. Capture Context: Future readers won't have the conversation context
4. Include Alternatives: Briefly mention options considered and why they were rejected
5. Acknowledge Trade-offs: Every decision has costs and benefits
6. Write Before/During Implementation: Don't wait until after
7. Keep Immutable: Rarely edit after acceptance; supersede instead

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Writing ADRs after decisions are implemented (loses context)
• Being too verbose (ADRs are not architecture documentation)
• Omitting alternatives considered (loses decision rationale)
• Not updating status when decisions change
• Creating ADRs for trivial decisions (use judgment)

Updating and Superseding ADRs

When a decision changes:

1. Create a new ADR documenting the new decision
2. Update the old ADR's status to "Superseded by ADR-XXXX"
3. Link between related ADRs
4. Don't delete or heavily modify old ADRs (history matters)

Example Prompts for Common ADR Types

Technology Selection

Create an ADR for choosing [Technology X] over [Technology Y] for [purpose].

Context includes:
- Current requirements: [list]
- Evaluation criteria: [performance, community, licensing, etc.]
- Alternatives considered: [list]
- Key trade-offs: [describe]

Pattern Adoption

Create an ADR for adopting [Pattern Name] pattern for [specific use case].

Context includes:
- Problem it solves: [describe]
- Where it applies: [scope]
- Alternatives considered: [list]
- Migration strategy: [if applicable]

Deprecation Decision

Create an ADR for deprecating [feature/component/approach].

Context includes:
- Current state and limitations: [describe]
- Replacement approach: [describe]
- Migration path: [describe]
- Timeline: [if applicable]

Architectural Boundary

Create an ADR for establishing [boundary/interface/contract].

Context includes:
- Components involved: [list]
- Interaction patterns: [describe]
- Stability requirements: [describe]
- Evolution strategy: [describe]

Tooling or Process

Create an ADR for introducing [tool/process] to address [problem].

Context includes:
- Current pain points: [describe]
- How it addresses the problem: [describe]
- Integration approach: [describe]
- Evolution path: [if phased]

Evolution of This Skill

This skill is part of a phased approach to ADR tooling (see ADR-0001):

• Phase 1 (Current): Skill provides template and process guidance
• Phase 2 (Future): /adr-new slash command for quick invocation
• Phase 3 (Future): Haiku sub-agent for drafting boilerplate
• Phase 4 (Future): Hooks to detect architecture changes without ADRs

Status updates will be reflected in ADR-0001.

Usage Example

User: "I want to document the decision to use Context7 MCP for documentation access"

Claude (using this skill):

1. Checks docs/adrs/ for existing ADRs (finds ADR-0000, ADR-0001)
2. Determines next number: ADR-0002
3. Creates docs/adrs/adr-0002-use-context7-mcp-for-documentation-access.md
4. Fills template with provided context
5. Updates docs/adrs/README.md table of contents
6. Confirms completion with user